It was lack of interest in Linux rather than the operating system's inherent security that left an Ubuntu laptop unbreached in a hacking contest, said the security expert who oversaw the contest.
"There was just no interest in Ubuntu," said Terri Forslof, manager of security response for 3Com's TippingPoint, which put up the cash prizes awarded at the contest last week at CanSecWest. "A contest such as this is not a measure of relative security between operating systems. It's not an accurate barometer."
Just because the laptop - a Sony running the Ubuntu 7.10 distribution of Linux - had been untouched doesn't mean that the operating system is any more secure than either Mac OS X or Windows Vista, both which fell to attacks.
"It was actually a lack of interest" on the part of the PWN To OWN contestants, Forslof said. "Shane's [Macaulay] exploit would have worked on Linux. He could have knocked it over. But [the contestants] get a lot more mileage out of attacks on the Mac or Windows," she continued.
"Linux, it is what it is. The code is a lot more transparent. But vulnerabilities for Mac and Windows, those are the ones that are going to get the press."
Of the three notebooks, the first to go down was a MacBook Air, which was hacked last Thursday, the second day of the three-day challenge, by Charlie Miller using a zero-day vulnerability in Safari. Friday, Macaulay breached a Windows Vista SP1-powered Fujitsu using a flaw in Adobe's Flash.
In both cases, the vulnerabilities were exchanged for cash prizes - US$10,000 for Miller, half that for Macaulay - and acquired by TippingPoint's bug bounty program, Zero Day Initiative (ZDI). The bugs have been reported to Apple and Adobe Systems, respectively, so that the vulnerabilities can be closed.
By design, PWN To OWN's first day was reserved for exploits of remote code vulnerabilities on the operating systems themselves. No one managed to crack a computer that day. Instead, it wasn't until the notebooks' attack exposure was expanded - first to any client-side application installed by default with the operating system, then to a larger group of third-party applications added to the machines - that the MacBook Air and Fujitsu dropped.
"I really wasn't expecting anything that first day," Forslof said. Not only are vulnerabilities meeting PWN To OWN's first day criteria harder to find and harder to exploit, but they're probably worth a lot more than the $20,000 TippingPoint offered that day, Forslof said. "We're talking about a worm-class issue here," she said.
"What a contest like this does show," Forslof said, "is that vulnerabilities are definitely moving up the stack."
That trend, from attacking the operating system to attacking applications, particularly those installed on desktop clients, has been building for months. The vast majority of vulnerabilities found, and when found then exploited, are now in client-side applications such as Internet Explorer, Microsoft Word, Firefox, Adobe Reader and others.
Part of that move toward applications, Forslof said, has been forced on hackers as operating systems have become more secure. This year's contest put that into relief when Macaulay initially had a tough time breaking into the Fujitsu notebook running Vista SP1.
"SP1 was a huge challenge to him," said Forslof. "When he walked in, he was strutting, he was going to own [that machine], he was going to break it in two minutes, he was going to wow the crowd."
That didn't happen, at least not immediately. Macaulay, said Forslof, had prepared an exploit, but had not tested it against Vista's Service Pack 1, which was released to the general public only two weeks ago.
" Microsoft has built a lot of things into its OS to make exploiting vulnerabilities more challenging," Forslof said, ticking off several defensive technologies, including ASLR (address space layout randomization). "Shane had to use some tricks to get that exploit to work on SP1."
"This is where a contest gets interesting," she said. "Vulnerabilities and exploits are hand in hand, of course, but they're two different animals. If Shane had taken this to another platform, it would have been a no brainer."
According to Forslof, the Flash vulnerability Macaulay exploited on the Vista SP1 notebook is multi-platform and is present, for example, on both Mac OS X and Linux.
Macaulay's difficulty in bringing down the Fujitsu was "immensely fascinating," added Forslof, for it showed researchers, working together and under pressure, as they tried one thing after another until they found an exploit solution.
"The sheer amount of difficulty [he had] exploiting that Flash vulnerability shows that Microsoft has started to make it more difficult for the bad guys," Forslof said when asked to draw some conclusions from PWN To OWN.
"Some of [Microsoft's] defense-in-depth strategies put a kink in the exploit. Everything is breakable, everything is exploitable, but what we'd like to do is narrow the group of people who can do it by making it harder for them," Forslof said.
Find your next job with techworld jobs